Welcome to our Custom Order Information Page

Here, you will find all the necessary details to help you place a special order tailored to your unique baking needs. Whether you're planning a celebration or simply want to enjoy a delightful treat, we are here to assist you in creating those memorable baking experiences.

Indulge in our custom desserts for all occasions. We’ve made hundreds of cakes and desserts and have great reviews to show for it. :)

All our cakes are three layers.

PRICING

BASIC BUTTERCREAM CAKES 

*added decorations & special buttercream effects such as ruffles will be extra. These prices are starting prices.

Scratch Baking Company ombre buttercream ruffles custom cake, bakery in Warwick, NY

Single Tier Cake

6"                 From $90  (Serves 12 -14)

8"                 From $150  (Serves 20 -24)

10"               From $230 (Serves 28-38)

12"               From $335 (Serves 40-56)

Servings Based on 1x2 inch servings

​

Finding Nemo custom birthday cake. Custom cake covered with Scratch Baking Company buttercream. Warwick, NY Bakery.

2 Tier Custom Cake

2 TIER BUTTERCREAM CAKES

6/8"                 From $250+ (Serves 28-35)    

Scratch Baking Company wedding cake made with vanilla buttercream.

3 Tier Custom Cake

3 TIER BUTTERCREAM CAKES

​6” + 8” + 10”   From $520+         (Serves 68-75)

Scratch Baking Company buttercream flowers, made in Warwick, NY

Decorated Cupcakes (Buttercream Flowers)

CUPCAKES

From $42.00 per DOZEN (min order 2 DOZEN)

Gluten Free Peanut Butter Kiss cookies made in our bakery in Warwick, NY

Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies

COOKIES (minimum order is 2 dozen per flavor)

Chocolate Chip Cookies $36 for 2 dozen

Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies (gf) $36 for 2 dozen

Maple Oatmeal Raisin $36 for 2 dozen

Cheesecake Squares are exclusively made by Scratch Baking Company and are the perfect individual desserts for your event.

Cheesecake Squares

CHEESECAKES

2"  From $96 for 2 dozen  (Minimum Order is 2 Dozen) *these are individual sized cheesecake squares

6"                 From $25  (Serves 6)

8"                 From $45 (Serves 10)

10"               From $85 (Serves 20)

FLAVORS


Basic cake flavors are:

vanilla

chocolate

red velvet

birthday cake (vanilla cake with sprinkles)

Basic buttercream fillings are:

vanilla

chocolate

chocolate fudge

strawberry

raspberry

cream cheese

peanut butter buttercream

oreo buttercream

dulce de Leche

nutella

——————————————————————

Premium Cake flavors are an extra $10:

carrot cake

Premium filling flavors are an extra $10:

lemon curd filling

strawberries and whipped cream

fresh fruit fillings